Who voted for what? 

As a teacher of VCE maths methods, one of the concepts that I have to explain to students is that of sampling. In particular, how can we ensure a non-biased sample? This might seem arcane but a real-world situation has recently arisen where the implications have affected the political debate. 

Soon after the UK EU referendum vote, Sky Data were projecting that only 36% of 18-24 year-olds voted. This was essentially an educated guess that was based, from what I can ascertain, on a variety of measures including polls of voting intentions. 

Nonetheless, the genie was out of the bottle and the impression formed that young voters were responsible for the UK making a bad choice. If they really felt strongly about Brexit then they should have voted.

Later, the results of a study by the LSE were published showing that ‘up to’ 70% of 18-24 year-olds did vote after all. This was based upon a poll conducted in the days after the vote where young people were contacted and asked, amongst other things, whether the result had made them cry.

Now the ball was hit to the other side of the court. It was no longer the fault of couch-loving youth voters. A poll with a better methodology than Sky Data proved this. The bad referendum result could not be pinned on them. Instead, those selfish old people were clearly to blame.

But here’s the rub.

Imagine that you are a 20-year-old. You wake up after the vote to the news that the world is about to end. Stocks have plummeted, the pound has fallen, old people and racists have sold your future down the river. They have ruined your future prospects. Then the phone rings.

“Did you vote?”

“How did you vote?”

“Did the result make you cry?”

We should already be alert to the notion that British voters may not always tell the truth to opinion pollsters. The failure of polling at the last UK general election was quite profound. It seems to me that a sample like this is likely to be biased. Even if the pollsters attempted to ‘correct for’ the fact that people tend to over report actually voting, how can we be sure that they corrected appropriately for this very unique set of circumstances?

One way to avoid this problem in future would be to collect data on the ages of voters at source, on actual ballot papers. But there is a good reason why we don’t do this.

In a democracy, everyone’s vote is equal. It doesn’t matter, in principal, how long you will have to live with the result. We don’t discount votes on the basis of life expectancy just like we don’t weight votes on level of educational attainment. The only data that matters is the number voting for a position or candidate.

I am not sure that I like the choice Britain made on the 23rd June but it was a democratic one. Slicing and dicing it doesn’t change that.

Advertisements

3 Comments on “Who voted for what? ”

  1. Most 18-24 year olds I spoke to did not vote, and at a similar age, neither did I. In my polling que, which was large, I saw no one under the age of 30 other than the children with the parents waiting.
    I genuinely think people do not take their democratic responsibilities seriously until about 30

  2. Chester Draws says:

    As with all statistics, does it pass the sniff test?

    Youngsters don’t generally vote. Suddenly, for this referendum they did? No, sorry, there is no way that passes.

    “78% said they would miss the right to live anywhere in the EU as well as the sense of being part of a European community.”

    Really? Four out of five young Britons seriously considering living outside Britain. I call BS on that too. For a start, in practice older people are just as likely to live outside Britain as younger ones, and the 80% figure for older ones is ridiculous. If those figures were remotely true, Remain would have romped home. (The figures show 1 in thirty Brits live in Europe, and that includes lots of people like me that have British passports but have never actually lived in Britain.)

    The results are part of an LSE electoral psychology initiative. They have exactly the same resemblance to actual political opinion that academic psychology has to how people actually behave.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s